▼

Monday, November 16, 2026

Album Review: Down - "Volume V"

Supergroups are tough, man.  First you have to get the right mix of talent and egos (and possibly a lack of the latter,) and then you have to find a creative spark beyond the creative energy that goes into each artist’s primary group.  To top it all off, every supergroup has to contend with being inevitably pitted against the legacy and accomplishment of each more established band.  It’s damn difficult, under all those inauspicious conditions, to concoct something more than the sum of its constituent parts.

Give Down credit for trying.  The band is as dedicated as a secondary act can be (or in the case of Phil Anselmo, possibly a fourth or fifth act at this point.)  Down certainly identifies itself as a real band with a real arc, something more material than just a group of friends who occasionally get together and throw some songs down.  This is a serious and going concern, one that doesn’t rush and takes their time to produce material they feel strongly about.  Hence, since 1995, this new record Volume V is only the fifth edition of released material.


At its core, Down wants to be a sludgier, doomier band than Pantera, Crowbar or Corrosion of Conformity, the three principal bands that the assembled musicians hail from.  Ever read the Si Spurrier graphic novel The Voice Said Kill? Well, it’s set in the backwater swamps of Louisiana and tries to impart to the reader the kind of odd, gritty, humidity-addled people that live out in those parts, and Down’s new album would be something of an appropriate soundtrack to that.  It’s bluesy and dour, twisted and soulful.


There’s also a tip of the cap in that Down, as ever, doesn’t sound like any of the three bands already mentioned.  It’s not as violent as Pantera, as plodding as Crowbar, or as teeth-baring as CoC, so point for finding a sound that is a similar frequency to all those things, but not identical to any of them.  Album closer “Twice-Told Tales” is the best example of the blues-laden, riff-heavy music that Down is about, and sounds distinct from its established contemporaries.


There’s nothing wrong with Volume V. Here’s the rub - part of the band’s appeal is the name recognition of the people in it.  And that’s fine for what it is; it gives the band an implied appeal and an automatic shot at establishing a real fan base.  This kind of music is largely dead in the mainstream, so there’s not a lot of competition out there for it.  So, if the audience is narrowed down to only folks who are clinging madly to their copy of Vulgar Display of Power or Blind, then Down will represent the continuation of the music they adore, just through a slightly different lens, especially the groove of “Merciful Fate,” which even features King Diamond (and his wife!)


For discerning listeners who are willing to peel back the superficial layer of music marketing and peer into the underground and do a little digging, there’s nothing on Volume V that’s not being done as well or better by any number of other bands.  Hell, Texas Hippie Coalition released two albums this year of roughly the same fare.  Hoaxed, The Heavy Eyes, Year of the Cobra, Sundrifter, Dunes, Castle Rat, Devil to Pay, a bunch of others, and probably a hundred bands playing in sweat-soaked clubs in NOLA have been carrying the torch and expanding the boundaries of this fuzzed-out branch of rock for years.  Which softens any potential impact the album has on a large portion of the audience.


Again, let’s go back; this says nothing about Down’s credibility.  Many supergroups are a quick cash-in or a throwaway gathering where some artists just wanted to work together and explore a possibility (remember Lulu?) Down isn’t that.  This is as serious and concerted effort by a band as any mainline band would be.  Volume V is good enough for what it is and what it’s trying to convey.  For the ambitious music fan however, there’s nothing novel here.


No comments:

Post a Comment